2026.11.10

In November 2026, The New York Times and several other U.S. newspapers filed copyright lawsuits against Brave Software, a company that collected web content and supplied it to AI companies. What stands out is that the defendant is a data supplier, not an AI model developer.
The case has not been decided. But regardless of the outcome, there are things companies buying data can check now. This post walks through five checks on source, copyright and contract terms to make before choosing a supplier.
A good supplier can name the publishers, institutions and databases behind its data. "Collected from across the web" is not an answer. If a supplier cannot give you a concrete source list, that alone is a warning sign.
Having data is not the same as having the right to provide it to customers. Check the basis on which the supplier obtained the data, such as agreements with original rights holders or authorized licensors, or open licenses. Then confirm that those rights extend to what is provided to you.
Whether data arrives by API or by file, a trustworthy supplier can explain how it gets to you. Ask:
Model training, retrieval-augmented generation (RAG), in-product display and redistribution may each require different rights. One point deserves emphasis. An API usage agreement and the rights to the content delivered through it must be confirmed separately. Paying for an API does not mean you can use the content inside it for any purpose. When permitted uses are spelled out in the contract, the risk of disputes over interpretation goes down.
Beyond liability, you need to know how your service will keep running when something goes wrong. Confirm these at the contract stage.
| What to check | Questions to ask |
|---|---|
| Rights warranty | What does the supplier warrant about its right to provide the data? |
| Dispute response | When a rights holder objects, when will you be notified and how will the supplier cooperate? |
| Operational action | How are suspension, deletion and replacement of affected data handled? |
| Liability | What are the scope, caps and exceptions of indemnification? |
RDPLINE is a data pipeline that delivers lawfully sourced data in real time as AI-Ready Data. If you ask about source and rights before quality, put these five questions to RDPLINE as well.
References